Ukraine and Trump

Trump has famously said that he could end the conflict in Ukraine in 24 hours, but it might not be that easy. The democrats and the American establishment, supported by the military-industrial complex, have no interest in peace. The Biden administration just decided to send another six billion to Ukraine in what has developed into an American proxy war. Trump just came up with a plan for a ceasefire and to start negotiating a peace plan. However, Russia trashed the plan pitched by Trump’s team to end the Russia-Ukraine conflict by deferring Kyiv’s NATO membership in exchange for a ceasefire.

For any kind of peace, Ukraine cannot join NATO, not now or in the future. As Biden’s obsession of NATO eastward expansion is one of the key reasons, maybe the key reason, for the conflict, it seems peculiar that a deferment would even been in the cards. Trump’s repeated criticism of Ukraine and U.S. funding for Kyiv, and his promise to end the war within a day, once in power, have prompted concerns among NATO allies about the compromises he might demand of Ukraine. Bottom line though, is that there will have to be some kind of compromise as Russia slowly but surely is winning.

It is not clear what details are in Trump’s so called peace plan, but the Wall Street Journal reported that Trump’s plans for a truce in Ukraine involve delaying Kyiv’s NATO membership by 20 years. This is clearly not a good idea and Russia would not agree to this. Another detail is to use the current geographical line of demarcation between Russia and Ukraine as demilitarized zone. This demilitarized zone would span nearly 1,290km. It remains unclear who would police the zone, but likely Europeans and the UK.

Under the plan, Ukraine would have to cede some of its eastern territory to Russia, including parts of Luhansk, Donetsk, Kherson and Zaporizhzhia. Russia has taken hold of about 20 percent of Ukrainian territory since 2014. If Trump were to offer Putin a deal in which Russia gets to effectively keep the Ukrainian territory it currently controls, there is a chance Russia would accept.

After all, Trump is in a strong position. He can sustain a long conflict as the U.S. wins from huge defense sales with zero US casualties. He could also escalate by sending more advanced weaponry and use more targeted precision missiles.

Ukraine had earlier stressed that any peace deal must involve nullifying Russian annexation of Ukrainian territory, including Crimea, which was annexed in 2014. This is not going to happen though, and Crimea is Russian historically, now and in the future. The other areas of eastern Ukraine are Russian-speaking and under Russian control, so it seems logical that the eastern parts will belong to Russia going forward.

With Russia rejecting a compromise over NATO membership, which Ukraine gets, but only 20 years later, it is unclear how Kyiv and Moscow can return to the negotiating table. Ukraine likely feels they need some kind of security if they hand over territory and stop fighting and NATO membership is the centerpiece of what Zelenskyy has been pushing as his peace plan.

Either way, NATO or not, there needs to be a plan that guarantees Ukraine’s security. That means either bilateral security guarantees from the West or cast-iron assurances that they will give Ukraine all the tools needed to defend themselves, rather like Israel or South Korea. A bilateral agreement might be of interest to Trump too as it would keep NATO out of it and there could be a more bilateral cooperation between Ukraine and the U.S. From a Russian perspective, it might be better to have a Ukraine aligned with the U.S. rather than NATO.  

Similar Posts

  • The American drug society

    The U.S. is a country with many problems such as high crime rate, homelessness, poor education, gun violence, race issues, immigration, affordability, extreme inequality, but the worst element might be drugs. There are drugs everywhere and it is getting worse.  The cost of drug abuse in the US is estimated to nearly $820 billion per…

  • U.S. savings habits

    Pandemic-era savings are less consequential today in sustaining consumer spending than they were a few years ago. That is not to say that all the sand has entirely spilled through the hourglass; households still have more cash on hand today than a linear trend extension from the prior cycle might suggest. A more interesting concept…

  • More troubles for Trump

    More polls show that the republicans are lagging in the polls heading into the November midterm elections. This is a problem for Trump as he thinks he is taking the right actions and losing the House and potentially losing the Senate would derail his MAGA agenda. The main reason for the pow poll numbers seem…

  • Rubio’s Euro speech

    A year after JD Vance shocked Europe at the Munich Security Conference with his speech about liberty and freedom and in effect accused Europe for authoritarianism and censorship and election interferences, it was Secretary of State Marco Rubio turn to give the speech this year. Last year, the Europeans were not mentally prepared for being…

  • U.S. – China trade war

    An economic conflict or trade war between the U.S. and China has been ongoing since January 2018, when president Trump began setting tariffs and other trade barriers on China with the goal of forcing it to make changes to what the U.S. says are longstanding unfair trade practices and intellectual property theft. The U.S. policies…